Skip to main content

Rustique Pies: Delicious, but where's the filling?

During the warm summer months up north near my country house, blueberries, blackberries and raspberries grow wild and free in many wooded areas.  The blueberries are the most bountiful and picking them is back breaking but oh so worth it.  I really enjoy blueberry pies and muffins, so when I heard of this new Rustique Pie Kitchen that opened in St. Henri, I knew I had to pay them a visit.

After a delicious lunch across the street at Campanelli's, I headed over to Rustique Pies for a little dessert.  Upon entering the quaint little shop, I was greeted with the most delicious smell of fresh baked pies and other sweet treats.  A really delicious smell that immediately caused me to drool.  I quickly decided that the best way to try a little bit of everything was to get a little bit of everything - duh!  I chose the six pie box and selected an array of little pies.  

The lemon meringue was absolutely delicious.  The crust was amazing, perfect - extraordinary!  The filling was just delicious and not overly lemony.  Then I tried the sugar pie.  The crust was again perfect, the best pie crust I have ever had to date.    Flaky, crumbly and just delicious, I have no other words to describe it - kudos to the chef!!!  The filling was OK, not the greatest I've had but it was still good.  The chocolate pie was really good, I enjoyed it a lot and so did my sister.  

Then came the fruit pies; blueberry, peach and cherry.  The crust as I said before is outstanding, but that doesn't mean that I don't want any filling.  We all found the pies to be overloaded with crust and lacking in the filling department.  The blueberry pie tasted the same as the cherry which tasted the same as the peach one.  I was not the only one to notice this.  Everyone who ate the pies with me agreed that all the pies had an excellent crust however they were lacking in flavour and couldn't tell the difference between each pie.  This was a huge disappointment!  

I will agree that the crust is hands down the best pie crust around, but I can't say the same about the fillings.  The lack of tasting real fruit in any of their fillings was really disappointing as I was really hoping to taste the best pies in town.  Maybe my expectations were too high, however I do think a pie place should specialize in fillings as well as the crust.   I will be back to sample more pies and try their other baked goods.  I heard their hello dolly squares and lemon bars are extraordinary, I will definitely be back to try them.           

Rustique Pie Kitchen on Urbanspoon


Popular posts from this blog

Le Santal, the very best of St. Martin

Vacation time is always the best time.  Planning every part of your trip and then finally getting to experience everything you hoped for.  This year, my girlfriends and I planned a last minute spontaneous trip to St. Martin with a stop in Anguilla.  I of course was excited for all the food.  The research started once my flight was booked, and did not stop until I felt we had more than enough options.  I can get obsessive, so I had to really narrow down my list.  At the top of my list were a few, but one kept reappearing, Le Santal.   Sitting on the beautiful beach of Sandy Ground St. Martin, Le Santal blew my expectations like no other restaurant has ever done before.  We pulled up to the restaurant where the valet and hostess were waiting for us.  Our car was taken to the parking lot and we were escorted to our table.  Our table was overlooking the water, so beautiful so calming, we really enjoyed the view.   The restaurant is gorgeous.  Elegantly decorated in white

Grumman 78 - A Taco heaven?

Scrolling through my pictures this weekend, I noticed ones from my lunch at Grumman 78 and immediately realized that I had never written a review on them - shame on me!  Better late than never right?  So here it is, a year late ... My visit to Grumman was so long ago, in fact it was at their Faubourg location that closed a while back.  Two friends and I headed over the Grumman for what we heard were the best tacos in town.  Arriving at their order counter, I quickly ordered two tacos (pork stick and the lamb curry taco), papas Grumman and a tomato and corn bread salad.   The first Taco I had was their "Pork Stick" topped with a delicious potato and egg salad.  When ordering this taco I thought I would be transported into a different taste dimension, maybe I was expecting too much.  It was good, but nowhere near as good as everyone made it seem.   I found it to be a bit lacking in flavour, I barely tasted anything expect the salad topping.  I enjoyed it but

Spiga; Italian cuisine on a French Island

Spiga Grand Case, St. Martin Since travelling to Italy, I have become such a snob when it comes to eating Italian food.  I don't enjoy pizza as much, except for a couple of places, pasta dishes seem bland and tasteless, and don't get me started on the meats.  I just don't get it.  Italian food used to be my favourite, but now, I just keep dreaming of the day I can go back and eat till  explode, literally!  I am saved sometimes as my co-worker is a from Italy and happens to be a killer cook.  She satisfies my gnocchi craving when I need it the most.  So when I came across Spiga on my restaurant quest of St. Martin, I was cautious, but hopeful.   We parked like typical locals, squished on some lawn on the side of the road, and walked in to the very cute restaurant.  It was quite busy, one table in particular was overly rowdy and obnoxious, nevertheless we were seated very quickly, a very big plus in my books.  We sat down, ordered drinks and waited hungrily to or